Being military I needed the reflective vest and bright colors, so I got this bag in orange... I have to respectfully disagree with this post, I think this bag is outstanding. I use it to get back and forth to work with lunches, gym gear and other miscellaneous items and find this bag to be perfect.
As you all know I'm sure, R6's have limited luggage, so this bag was a must for me. I can't speak to the durability as you had yours longer, however I've owned a lot of bags in my day and the damage you have is rather common for most bags at some point (6 months is not good, however...). The straps are solid, and keep the bag locked in on my back with more than your average shoulder straps (no sliding around like a normal backpack), I ride to work in the pre-sunrise hours and think (personally) that the orange and reflectivity are essential!! It has a spot for some small tools, and even some first-aid stuff.
I definitely agree with you on the durability issue, but think this bag is absolutely essential for someone who needs to bring more than themselves anywhere on a bike... well maybe not essential, but I just like the bag!! I'm new though, so maybe I just don't know yet :screwy
Just wanted to add my opinion to this thread... not wanting to offend